
"Just Change
The Washer"
They Said
A customer asked me to fix their dripping bath tap. I told them to replace it. They didn't listen. Now they've paid double.
The Call That Made Me Write This
A customer called about a dripping bath tap. Fair enough - happens all the time in this hard water area. But the moment I walked in and saw the tap, I knew exactly what we were dealing with.
Cheap tap. Lever handles. That "modern" look that comes with every new-build bathroom these days. This wasn't a traditional tap with a washer you can replace for 50p. This was a quarter-turn tap with ceramic disc cartridges - and that changes everything.
What Quarter-Turn Taps Actually Are
Quarter-turn taps are called that because they go from fully off to fully on in just a 90-degree turn (a quarter of a full rotation). They use ceramic discs inside instead of traditional rubber washers.
- Easy to spot: Lever handles instead of traditional round handles, smooth operation, only need a small turn
- Usually cheap taps: They look modern but the quality is often poor
- No washers inside: Two ceramic discs that slide against each other - when they wear, you can't just replace a washer
I Told Him Straight
I explained the situation clearly: "We can take a look and see if we can do anything, but honestly, it's not worth changing the cartridges. These taps are too far gone. Best thing is a new tap."
I quoted him for a new bath tap - around £175 supplied and fitted. Simple job, no messing about.
But he wanted to try anyway.
The Problem: We got the cartridge out - and of course, the ceramic discs were completely gone. Worn through. We tried the old tricks - turning things over, cleaning them up - but it was too far gone. As I'd said from the start.
Then It Got Worse
Here's where things got complicated. To get a replacement cartridge, you need to take the old one AND the handle to a plumbing shop. They're not standardized - every cheap tap manufacturer uses slightly different sizes. You can't just buy "a cartridge" and expect it to fit.
And to make matters worse, the gate valves on both the hot and cold wouldn't properly isolate the water. So we've got a bath tap slowly pouring into the bath with no way to stop it. Not exactly something you can just leave.
I told him again: "Look, you need a new tap. This isn't going to work."
He Asked Us To Try The Shop Anyway
Against my advice, he asked us to take the cartridge and handle to the plumbing suppliers to try and find a replacement.
So we did. Wasted our time going to the shop with the cartridge and handle. They had nothing like it. Different spline count, different dimensions, wrong thread size. As I'd expected.
Came back and told him: he needed a new tap. The same thing I'd said at the very beginning.
The Maths Don't Lie
Option A: Listen to the plumber
New bath tap: ~£175
Visits: 1
Total: £175
Option B: "Try fixing it"
Visit 1 (diagnosis + try repair): £70-90
Visit 2 (shop run + return): £70-90
New tap (eventually): £175
Total: £300+
Why This Keeps Happening
I understand why people want to try repairing things. Nobody wants to spend money unnecessarily. But here's what customers don't realize about quarter-turn taps:
- They're not designed to be repaired. These cheap taps are built to a price point. The manufacturers never expected anyone to fix them.
- Cartridges aren't standardized. Unlike traditional washers which are universal, every cheap tap brand uses slightly different cartridge sizes.
- Even if you find one, it costs almost as much as a new tap. A quality replacement cartridge (if you can find it) might be £30-50. For a tap that cost £40 new.
- If one side's gone, the other's not far behind. Ceramic discs wear at similar rates. Fix one side, and you'll be back in six months for the other.
The Lesson (Since You Asked)
When a plumber tells you to replace something, there's usually a very good reason.
We're not trying to upsell you. We're not trying to make more money. We're trying to save you from paying twice for the same job. We've seen this exact scenario hundreds of times. We know how it ends.
I hate these jobs. Not because they're difficult - because I have to charge someone for my time to prove a point I made an hour ago. It doesn't feel good for anyone.
You think you know better. You don't. You've been warned.
How To Spot Quarter-Turn Taps
Quick Identification Guide
- Lever handles instead of round cross-head or capstan handles
- Only turns 90 degrees from fully off to fully on
- Very smooth operation - no grinding or resistance
- "Modern" looking - often chrome, came with a new-build or budget bathroom suite
- Lightweight - quality taps are heavy. These feel light and plasticky
What You Should Actually Do
If you've got a dripping quarter-turn tap and you're wondering whether to try and fix it:
- 1Call a plumber and be honest. Tell them it's a cheap tap with lever handles. We'll know immediately what you're dealing with.
- 2Listen to the advice. If we say replace it, we're not trying to rip you off. We're trying to save you money in the long run.
- 3Invest in quality this time. Buy a proper tap with traditional washers, or a quality mixer tap with replacement cartridges that are actually available.
- 4Get your gate valves checked. If they won't isolate, that's a separate problem you need to sort before it becomes an emergency.
The Bottom Line
Quarter-turn taps with ceramic disc cartridges are disposable items designed to look nice and cost little. When they fail, they've done their job. Replace them, don't repair them. And when your plumber tells you this upfront, maybe consider that they might actually know what they're talking about.
More Technical Experience
Real-world plumbing insights from the field - the stuff they don't teach you in manuals
"Easy Fit" Kitchen Tap Nightmare
Another case of marketing names not matching reality - when "easy fit" means "impossible to remove."
Read story →Complete Tap Repair Guide
When taps CAN be repaired, how we do it - the full professional process explained.
Read guide →Mixer Tap Installation Guide
How to choose quality mixer taps that will actually last and can be serviced.
Read guide →Dripping Tap? Get Honest Advice
I'll tell you straight whether your tap can be repaired or needs replacing. No games, no wasted time, no paying twice for the same job.
Serving Andover, Marlborough & Hungerford - Hampshire, Wiltshire & Berkshire